Trade Buzz Continues to Surround Islanders and Brock Nelson
As the 4 Nations Tournament continues and the 2024-25 NHL trade deadline approaches, trade rumors surrounding New York Islanders center Brock Nelson remain persistent. Michael Russo of The Athletic recently reported that Nelson’s status was a major talking point during 4 Nations Media Day, fueling speculation even further—despite Nelson’s desire to quiet the chatter.
A key factor in the uncertainty is Islanders general manager Lou Lamoriello, who is known for keeping his plans under wraps, leaving fans and media to speculate on Nelson’s future.
What’s the Latest on Brock Nelson and the Islanders?
At 32 years old, Nelson has been a cornerstone of the Islanders’ lineup since 2013. Selected 30th overall in the 2010 NHL Draft, he has developed into one of the league’s most dependable two-way centers. His ability to consistently produce offensively and provide veteran leadership makes him a highly valuable asset—especially for teams looking to strengthen their playoff push.
Nelson is also set to become an unrestricted free agent, positioning him for a significant payday. Given his consistent scoring output of 25 to 35 goals per season, he is expected to attract plenty of interest if the Islanders decide to move him.
Reports suggest that Nelson would prefer to stay with the Islanders and secure a contract extension before the trade deadline. However, general manager Lou Lamoriello has a reputation for being cautious with long-term, high-dollar deals—especially for aging veterans—which could complicate negotiations.
Can the Islanders Afford to Lose Nelson for Nothing?
With Nelson expressing his desire to remain in New York, the Islanders are faced with two key questions. First, are they willing to meet his contract demands? Second, if they aren’t, can they afford to let him walk without getting any return? Lamoriello has a history of allowing key players to enter free agency rather than dealing them early.
Nelson’s current deal carries a $6 million cap hit—reasonable for a player with his consistent offensive production. Even with a potential pay increase, a similar figure would still be fair, especially with the rising salary cap.
Teams Eyeing Nelson: Colorado, New Jersey, and Toronto
If the Islanders decide to field trade offers, several teams could emerge as serious contenders. According to The Athletic’s Michael Russo, three franchises stand out as potential landing spots: the Colorado Avalanche, New Jersey Devils, and Toronto Maple Leafs.
Colorado Avalanche
The Avalanche have been searching for a second-line center to complement Nathan MacKinnon for a few seasons. While Casey Mittelstadt has shown promise, he may not be the long-term solution. Adding Nelson would give Colorado a reliable and experienced scoring option.
Potential return: The Islanders could demand a package featuring a young forward or a high draft pick to strengthen their future.
New Jersey Devils
New Jersey has been aggressive in seeking upgrades at center. With Nico Hischier currently sidelined, the Devils are looking to bolster their lineup behind Jack Hughes. Nelson’s veteran presence and two-way ability would be an ideal fit for a team pushing for a deep playoff run.
Potential return: The Devils have a deep prospect pool and could offer a young defenseman like Simon Nemec, depending on the asking price.
Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto has long been in the market for a legitimate second-line center to support Auston Matthews. While John Tavares remains productive, adding Nelson would provide additional scoring depth and a strong two-way presence for the postseason.
Potential return: The Leafs could build a package around top prospects like Easton Cowan or Fraser Minten, along with a draft pick, to entice the Islanders.
Will the Trade Rumors Become Reality?
At this point, Nelson’s future remains uncertain. The Islanders’ performance leading up to the deadline will likely dictate Lamoriello’s decision. If the team remains in playoff contention, Nelson may stay as an “own rental,” with extension talks revisited in the offseason. However, if the Islanders falter, trade discussions could escalate quickly.
Nelson has made it clear that winning is his top priority, and while he has been loyal to the Islanders, he may be open to moving if he feels the team isn’t positioned to compete for a Stanley Cup.
Given the blockbuster trades already taking place this season, Nelson’s situation is shaping up to be one of the biggest storylines to watch as the deadline nears. If a move happens, expect it to come down to the wire.
Leave a Reply