Newsweek’s Zach Pressnell recently proposed that the Atlanta Braves trade for two-time All-Star shortstop Trevor Story to replace Orlando Arcia.
Arcia, who struggled offensively in 2024 with a .218 average and a .625 OPS, has had an even worse spring. In 16 games this year, he’s gone just 4-for-33 (.121) with no extra-base hits, two RBIs, and three walks.
If Arcia’s slump continues into the regular season, his spot could quickly become a point of frustration for Braves fans. Pressnell, in fact, has already suggested it might be time to move on from Arcia. On March 19, he proposed a trade for Story, a two-time All-Star shortstop, to take over the position.
Pressnell speculated that the Braves would likely have to part with a top pitching prospect, like Hurston Waldrep, and another high-level prospect, such as Nacho Alvarez Jr., to acquire Story. While such a deal wouldn’t come cheap, Pressnell argues that the Braves need to strengthen shortstop if they want to compete with teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers in the National League.
Story, who is currently under a six-year, $140 million contract, has posted an .833 OPS and hit .265 with a .501 slugging percentage over 908 MLB games. However, a trade for Story is unlikely. His recent performance with the Red Sox has been less than stellar, and injuries have plagued him in recent years. His batting line of .232/.296/.397 since joining Boston, coupled with his age (32) and injury history, makes him a questionable acquisition for the Braves.
Story’s past success with the Colorado Rockies, including two All-Star selections and two Silver Slugger awards, was aided by playing in the hitter-friendly Coors Field. His struggles in Boston, where he hasn’t been able to consistently slug above .400, make him a less appealing option for the Braves.
In addition, taking on Story’s $140 million contract would be a risky move, especially when considering the potential trade cost of two top prospects. It’s been noted that Story’s deal is one of the worst for the Red Sox heading into 2025, according to Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly.
Instead, the Braves might be better off sticking with Arcia for now and turning to Nick Allen as a short-term option if Arcia continues to struggle. Allen has impressed with a .393 average and three extra-base hits in 13 games this spring.
If Arcia doesn’t improve in 2025, the Braves could explore trade possibilities later in the season, including Story, if the Red Sox are open to sending cash along with him, similar to their deal with Chris Sale. But unless such a scenario occurs, a trade for Story doesn’t seem likely.
Leave a Reply