Trade Pitch Has Islanders Sending Defenseman to Metro Rival

Trade Proposal Has Islanders Moving Noah Dobson to Metro Rival

The New York Islanders face a crucial decision about defenseman Noah Dobson. The 25-year-old, a right-shot defenseman, is a restricted free agent this summer, and Evolving Hockey projects him to land an eight-year contract worth over $10 million annually. While New York has the cap space to accommodate such a deal, the Islanders are contemplating whether trading him might be a more strategic move.

The Islanders’ dilemma isn’t about financial flexibility, but rather concerns regarding Dobson’s future performance. After an impressive 2023-24 season in which he scored 70 points, Dobson’s production dropped significantly in 2024-25, managing just 39 points in 71 games. This inconsistency raises questions about his true level of ability—whether he is a top-tier 70-point producer or merely a secondary scoring presence from the blue line.

If the Islanders decide to trade Dobson, they will be looking for immediate value rather than just picks or prospects. One potential trade partner could be the Philadelphia Flyers, who recently acquired Trevor Zegras from the Anaheim Ducks but are still in need of defensive upgrades.

Proposed Trade:

• Philadelphia Flyers Receive: Defenseman Noah Dobson

• New York Islanders Receive: Forward Owen Tippett and the 22nd pick in the 2025 NHL Draft (originally held by the Colorado Avalanche)

How Dobson Strengthens the Flyers’ Defense:
The Flyers have a solid defensive group but could certainly use an upgrade. With Rasmus Ristolainen potentially on the trade block, adding Dobson would bolster their blue line significantly. His arrival would provide Philadelphia with a top-pairing right-shot defenseman, allowing Travis Sanheim to shift back to the left side, strengthening both the left and right sides of the defense.

The Flyers would need to negotiate a contract with Dobson before finalizing any trade. However, this deal would address a key need for Philadelphia while also allowing New York to acquire a valuable forward and draft pick. It could be a mutually beneficial move for both teams.