Saints’ Quarterback Situation for 2025: A Complex Outlook
As the Saints enter the second week of the offseason, the focus will intensify with player evaluations, coaching interviews, and key decisions on the horizon. General manager Mickey Loomis will address the media, providing further insight into the team’s direction. One of the critical areas of focus will be the quarterback position, especially with ongoing changes in coaching staff and roster management.
Quarterback Overview for the Saints
- Players Under Contract: Derek Carr, Spencer Rattler, Jake Haener, Ben DiNucci (reserve/future)
- Free Agent Outlook: None
- Priority Level: High
While the Saints’ defense also needs attention, the quarterback position is a crucial focus as New Orleans contemplates its future under a new head coach. Before making any decisions, let’s break down the numbers from the 2024 season.
Derek Carr’s 2024 Performance
Although Carr didn’t meet the NFL’s statistical threshold (306 passing attempts), he played in 10 games, finishing with 2,145 passing yards, 15 touchdowns, 5 interceptions, and a 67.7% completion rate. His 101.0 passer rating was among the league’s top performers, ranking just behind Josh Allen and Tua Tagovailoa. His average yards per attempt increased to 7.7, putting him on par with notable quarterbacks like Justin Herbert and Kirk Cousins.
Spencer Rattler’s 2024 Performance
After Carr’s injury, Rattler started 6 games but did not secure a win. Despite some struggles, including a 70.4 passer rating, Rattler’s experience was crucial for the team. His stats included 1,317 yards, 4 touchdowns, and 5 interceptions, with an average of 5.8 yards per completion. He also faced significant pressure, getting sacked 22 times.
What Should the Saints Aim for in 2025?
The Offseason Dilemma
The key question for the Saints is whether Derek Carr will remain their starter in 2025. His current contract, which includes a substantial cap hit, could be restructured to save the team $31 million, but this decision will be influenced by the team’s direction under a new head coach. Carr’s $40 million contract decision looms large, as it includes a roster bonus and guaranteed money due on the third day of the new league year. While Carr has stated he won’t take a pay cut, a restructure is still possible.
If the Saints decide to move on from Carr, they could release him post-June 1 to save $30 million, though they would still carry his salary in 2025. The likelihood of Carr returning in 2025 is high, but the team’s future direction will shape this decision.
If the Saints embrace a rebuild, they might consider giving Rattler the starting role while bringing in a veteran to compete, such as Jimmy Garoppolo, Carson Wentz, or Josh Dobbs. The draft could also offer potential, though this year’s quarterback class isn’t particularly strong.
Coaching Changes and Future Outlook
The Saints could also face changes in their coaching staff, with the offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach positions potentially in flux. While Andrew Janocko has shown promise, inconsistency from the offensive scheme and coaching staff raises questions. More turnover might hinder progress, so stability in coaching could be essential for success in 2025.
Ultimately, the Saints face a pivotal offseason as they work to end a four-year playoff drought. Decisions on the quarterback and coaching staff will be central to determining their competitiveness in the NFC South next season. The team’s future trajectory will hinge on whether they opt for continuity with Carr or take a more transformative approach.
Leave a Reply