In the midst of an exciting season for Washington State University football, the spotlight has turned to quarterback John Mateer. With a promising start to the year, including a solid 4-1 record, the Cougars have displayed flashes of brilliance. Yet, it is clear that Mateer’s deep ball accuracy remains a question mark. As he approaches the next challenge against Fresno State, the question arises: what does Mateer need to unlock a more consistent deep ball?

When the coaching staff chose Mateer as the starting quarterback, they did so with confidence in his natural talent. His physical attributes, notably his powerful arm, and his ability to lead were key factors. However, the very qualities that made him an appealing choice also brought with them a tendency for inconsistency, particularly on deep throws. Mateer has connected on several long passes, one of which helped keep the Cougars competitive in their recent game against Boise State. Yet, with a completion rate of just 38% on throws of 20-plus yards, it’s evident that he has work to do.

One of the fundamental issues plaguing Mateer’s deep throws appears to be a lack of composure and progression in his reads. Head coach Jake Dickert highlighted this problem following the loss to Boise State. During that game, Mateer had moments where he seemed to rush his decisions, particularly on designed shot plays. Instead of surveying the field for potential options, he became fixated on his primary target, often leading to missed opportunities and turnovers. The interception thrown during the Apple Cup against Washington exemplified this pattern. Mateer locked onto his receiver, underthrew the ball, and failed to read the defense effectively.

In the critical final moments of the first half against Boise State, Mateer had a chance to tie the game but made a similar mistake. He had been methodically moving the offense forward, completing eight consecutive passes. Yet, when he locked onto Williams in the end zone, he missed a lurking safety, resulting in another costly interception. Mateer recognized this error, stating, “My eyes were in the wrong spot. Tried to force it in there.” This lack of vision on the field has been a recurring theme, particularly when targeting deep routes.

Examining Mateer’s statistics reveals further insights into his deep ball struggles. While he has shown capability on the sidelines, completing 7 of 15 passes to the left for 228 yards and three touchdowns, his performance up the middle tells a different story. With just 2 of 8 completions for 82 yards in that area, he has been notably less effective, which can hinder the offensive scheme. It’s clear that while he has the physical tools, mental adjustments must accompany them to improve his performance.

Mateer’s inconsistencies extend beyond just poor reads. At times, he has struggled with touch and timing on deep throws. A missed opportunity in the win over San Jose State highlighted this issue when he failed to connect with Kris Hutson, who was wide open over the middle. In another instance during the Boise State game, Mateer had Hutson in the end zone but underthrew the pass, leaving the receiver frustrated and the play ineffective. “I’ve never thought it’s been a struggle of mine, but apparently it has been,” Mateer admitted. “That’s gonna be something I’m gonna work on… I’ll get better.” This recognition of his weaknesses is a positive sign, suggesting that Mateer is committed to refining his skills.

A significant factor affecting Mateer’s deep ball performance is the protection provided by the offensive line. In the loss to Boise State, the Cougars’ offensive line struggled, allowing seven sacks—the highest number in three seasons. This inconsistency upfront puts added pressure on the quarterback and limits his ability to execute deep throws. When he is kept clean, Mateer’s statistics improve dramatically: a 64% completion rate, 1,252 yards, and ten touchdowns. However, when faced with pressure, his completion percentage drops to 36%, and he struggles to make plays. Better protection from the offensive line could provide Mateer with the time he needs to go through his progressions and deliver more accurate deep throws.

As the coaching staff continues to evaluate the offensive line, adjustments are needed. Right tackle Fa’alili Fa’amoe, who struggled in his return from injury, and left guard Rod Tialavea, who has faced challenges in his performances, have contributed to this issue. The line’s shifting configuration has not allowed for the consistency that is vital for a young quarterback to develop confidence. Coach Dickert has indicated that the team is working towards solidifying the starting five offensive linemen, which should help stabilize the protection for Mateer going forward.

As he progresses in his development, there are signs that Mateer has the potential to improve his deep ball accuracy. In a positive turn, his recent touchdown pass to Williams—a perfectly placed 33-yard throw in the fourth quarter—showed that he is capable of making big plays. While he might have leaned back a little too much during the throw, the placement of the ball demonstrated his ability to execute under pressure. With time and practice, Mateer can build on these moments and translate them into greater consistency.

Moreover, it’s essential to consider the mental aspect of being a quarterback at this level. For Mateer, part of unlocking his deep ball may involve boosting his confidence and trust in his own abilities. A quarterback must have the mental fortitude to remain calm under pressure, trust his instincts, and be willing to take calculated risks. As he gains more experience, particularly in high-pressure situations, he can develop the poise necessary to make those critical throws downfield.

Mateer’s journey this season serves as a reminder of the challenges that young quarterbacks face as they transition into starting roles. It’s not just about physical attributes; mental acuity, decision-making, and the ability to read defenses are crucial components of success. While he has demonstrated flashes of potential, the key to unlocking a more consistent deep ball lies in addressing the multifaceted challenges he faces. This includes improving his decision-making, enhancing his timing and touch, and ensuring that he receives the protection needed from his offensive line.

As the Cougars gear up for their matchup against Fresno State, it will be essential for Mateer to apply the lessons learned from previous games. With a focus on improving his reads and maintaining composure in the pocket, he can take significant steps toward becoming a more effective quarterback. The road ahead is filled with challenges, but with dedication and a willingness to learn, John Mateer has the opportunity to elevate his game and lead Washington State to success.