D-Backs Dilemma: Navigating the Potential Loss of Ketel Marte
As the Arizona Diamondbacks anxiously await the results of Ketel Marte’s MRI, the team is facing a crucial period that could significantly impact their season. Marte, who suffered a left ankle contusion during a game against the Philadelphia Phillies on Saturday night, is a key player whose absence could be deeply felt. His injury not only affects the team’s lineup but also puts a spotlight on the depth options the Diamondbacks have at their disposal.
Marte’s collision with Garrett Stubbs at second base led to his removal from the game, and although he attempted to play through the pain on Sunday, it was clear that the injury was serious. Marte’s return to the lineup on Monday was met with cautious optimism, but just one swing into his at-bat, the severity of his injury became apparent. Marte appeared to roll his ankle and crumpled to the ground, though he managed to finish his at-bat after a visit from the trainer and manager Torey Lovullo. Despite his efforts to stay in the game, Marte was eventually replaced by Kevin Newman.
Lovullo’s post-game comments painted a somewhat optimistic picture, describing the injury as a “re-aggravation” of the original issue rather than a new problem. He assured that the MRI, scheduled for Tuesday morning, was more of a precautionary measure to ease concerns rather than an indication of severe damage. The hope is that the MRI results will confirm that Marte’s injury is manageable and that he can return to the lineup without significant delay.
Marte’s impact on the Diamondbacks cannot be overstated. With a batting average of .298, 30 home runs, and 81 RBIs, he has been an offensive force. His defensive capabilities, particularly his Gold Glove-caliber performance, further cement his value to the team. Marte currently leads the National League with a 6.2 WAR, surpassing even notable players like Shohei Ohtani. Losing a player of his caliber could potentially derail the Diamondbacks’ season, especially as they push towards the postseason.
The Diamondbacks have already shown resilience in dealing with injuries this season. They successfully managed the absence of Christian Walker by acquiring Josh Bell, who has been red-hot since joining the team. Additionally, Adrian Del Castillo’s impressive start in place of Gabriel Moreno has provided a much-needed boost. However, replicating Marte’s level of production would be a formidable challenge, given his unique combination of hitting prowess and defensive excellence.
In the event that Marte is required to go on the Injured List (IL), the Diamondbacks have a few potential solutions to fill the gap. The most straightforward move would be to have Kevin Newman step in as the everyday second baseman. Newman has had a solid season, filling in at shortstop during Geraldo Perdomo’s absence and performing admirably in various roles. With a batting line of .280/.315/.386 and 23 RBIs, Newman could provide a reliable, if not spectacular, presence at second base.
Another option for the Diamondbacks is to recall Blaze Alexander from Triple-A Reno. Alexander started the season on the major league roster and showed promise in April with a .312 batting average and a .941 OPS. However, his defensive struggles and subsequent slump at the plate led to his demotion. Despite hitting only .214 in July, Alexander has rebounded in August, batting .324 with six extra-base hits. His recent performance suggests he could be a valuable asset if given another chance.
Adding switch-hitter Sergio Alcantara to the 40-man roster and calling him up could also be a strategic move. Alcantara, known for his ability to bat left-handed against right-handed pitching, could provide a different dynamic compared to the right-handed Newman’s and Alexander’s. In Triple-A this year, Alcantara has posted a .273 batting average and an .808 OPS against right-handers. His major league career shows a .655 OPS against righties, compared to a lower .546 OPS against lefties, indicating that he could be a useful platoon option.
Alcantara’s history with the Diamondbacks adds another layer to the decision. Originally signed as a teenager in 2012, he was traded to the Detroit Tigers in 2017 and made his MLB debut that year. He returned to the Diamondbacks in 2022, hitting .241 with a .688 OPS, including a memorable walk-off homer against the Dodgers. His familiarity with the organization could make him a seamless addition if the team decides to go this route.
One notable absence from the conversation is top prospect Jordan Lawlar, who has been on the injured list with a hamstring injury. Lawlar is still working his way back to playing shape and is not currently an option for a major league call-up. His progress will be closely monitored, but for now, the team must rely on the existing depth options.
As the Diamondbacks await the MRI results and plan their next steps, the uncertainty surrounding Marte’s injury looms large. The team’s ability to adapt and effectively utilize their depth options will be crucial in mitigating the impact of his potential absence. Whether it’s through Kevin Newman’s steady play, Blaze Alexander’s resurgence, or Sergio Alcantara’s versatility, the Diamondbacks need to find a way to fill Marte’s shoes and maintain their competitive edge.
In the end, the health of Ketel Marte and the team’s response to his injury will be pivotal in determining the trajectory of the Diamondbacks’ season. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely as the situation unfolds, hoping for the best but preparing for the challenges that may lie ahead. The Diamondbacks have shown resilience and adaptability throughout the season, and how they navigate this latest hurdle will be a testament to their determination and depth.
